The Best of Abbott & Costello - The Franchise Collection Volume 2 [Universal]

 

Do you know what your children are watching?

By NICK ZEGARAC

"The Best of Abbott & Costello - The Franchise Collection Volume 2" effectively gathers together another bumper crop of films that made up the middle of Bud and Lou's tenure at Universal Studios. Highlights on this two-disc edition include the whimsical "The Time of Their Lives" (1946), a film not well received in its time, but one that has proven to be an enduring classic in the A&C canon. Bud plays the dual role of Cuspert Greenway/Dr. Greenway, a footman in servitude to master Tom Danbury during the 1800s and his psychiatrist ancestor set in 1946. Cuspert's treachery against Horatio (Lou Costello) results in his death and that of Tom's fiancée, Mistress Melody (Marjorie Reynolds). From here on the story leaps forward to present day. Horatio and Melody, having been cursed upon their murders as traitors to America's independence, remain bound to Danbury Acres until crack of doom. But when they begin to haunt Dr. Greenway and his guests living at the refurbished historical landmark, a ray of hope develops that might finally set their spirits free.

In "Here Come the Co-eds" (1945) Bud and Lou are a couple of caretakers, hiding out from the police at Bixby College, an all girl's school. The film features The Hour Of Enchantment all girl's orchestra and choir, and a riotous basketball game in which Lou, after being hit on the head, believes that he is Daisy Dimple, the world's greatest female basketball player.

In "Hit the Ice" (1943) -- the boys take off to Sun Valley for skiing, a prospect that falls apart when a mob boss decides to hide out at the same resort.

This collection also features a handful of awful films. "The Wistful Widow of Wagon Gap" (1947) is a genuinely boring film in which Lou attempts to win the heart of a crotchety widow (Marjorie Maine) in order to secure her wealthy fortune, but whose adult children have other ideas. Lou generally is abused by everyone in the cast and there's a genuine strain on the relationship between A&C by this time.

In "The Naughty Nineties" (1945) Bud and Lou are performers on a riverboat, but the only salvation from this film is an extended version of the now legendary "Who's On First" skit. (Footnote: "Who's on First" is performed in a truncated version in "One Night In The Tropics" also. That film is available on "The Best of ... Volume One.")

The bad lot of apples reaches its rotten core with "Little Giant" (1946), a really boring hodge-podge in which Lou is a vacuum cleaner salesman working for Bud. This collection is rounded out by a couple of mediocre productions; "In Society" (1944), a trifle in which the boys crash a society party to help a chorus girl fall in love with a rich playboy, and "Buck Privates Come Home" (1947), a rehash of skits from previous films with the tack on of having Bud and Lou smuggle a little French girl back to America after the war.

Over all, the transfers in this collection are a mixed bag in image quality. While some films like "The Time of Their Lives" exhibit little to no age-related artifacts, others like "The Wistful Widow..." have not worn well at all. At its worst you will get a transfer riddled in age-related artifacts, minor edge enhancement, mis-registration and considerable film grain. At its best, the picture quality is outstanding -- leading me to think that some of these transfers were blessed with a meticulous digital restoration, while others got shafted. The audio for all the films is mono but very nicely presented.

» Buy the DVD


Ask us about exclusive sponsorships


©  Critics Inc. All rights reserved. See Terms of Use.

 

AMAZON.COM