|
By
NICK ZEGARAC
By the time Joseph L.
Mankiewicz premiered All About Eve (1950) he had
already won a pair of back to back Academy Awards
for Best Director and Best Screenplay on A Letter
To Three Wives the year before; a towering
achievement that was to be impressively matched by
this film – perhaps his most perfectly realized
screen creation.
In his day, Mankiewicz work was often criticized
as lacking cinematic staging – the perception
being that his characters are too intelligent for
film audiences, their dialogue and nuances more
theatrical in mood and tempo. The point is valid
only superficially, for the subtext in any
Mankiewicz movie is far superior to any
misperceived ‘lacking' in camera prowess. Indeed,
Mankiewicz was to muse years later that in his
movies it was the actors – rather than the camera
– that were required to act!
In this respect then, All About Eve remains the
quintessentially urbane and sophisticated
melodrama about show folk; a critique of the
Teflon-coated smug superiority held dearly within
the theatrical establishment turned on its end.
The film is a microcosm for viperous social
climbers and cutthroat sensationalists seething
with venom and insecurity.
After first choice to play grand diva Margo
Channing actress Claudette Colbert injured her
back, Mankiewicz turned to larger than life screen
diva, Bette Davis to assuage into the part. It was
a move not entirely embraced by 20th Century-Fox
whose top brass were well aware that Davis's last
few movies had pointed to a definite downturn in
both her popularity and boxoffice.
Davis was herself nearing forty and suffering from
the same anxieties as her fictional character.
Indeed, since her release from Warner Bros. (the
studio that had groomed her into superstardom),
Davis discovered that she had quietly become
unemployable overnight. Thus, in the many lean
years that were to follow Davis would acknowledge
"…not everything I do is quality, but I chose the
best from what I am offered."
From Mankiewicz however, Davis had nothing to
fear. His screenplay delivers a revealing look at
base classicism and greed behind all that publicly
glitters. His critique of human fallibility is
bang on and with Davis in the driver's seat
Mankiewicz is guaranteed a star who completely
understands his material. Reflecting years later
on the temporary resuscitation of her film career
at Fox, Davis generously acknowledged Mankiewicz
for his faith in her – "I owe it all to Joe. He
resurrected me from the dead."
After a brief prologue at the Sarah Siddon's
Society, exclusively narrated by sinister poisoned
pen columnist, Addison DeWitt (George Sanders),
the rest of the film's narrative is told entirely
in flashback. Margo Channing (Davis) is preparing
after her last stage performance to see
lover/director, Bill Samson (Gary Merrill) off to
Hollywood. Despite their considerable age
difference, Bill worships the ground Margo walks
on though neither Bill's commitment or his love
are enough to convince Margo that she is perhaps
making a terrible error in judgment by loving one
man so completely.
Margo's continued success on the stage is largely
due to her enduring friendship/partnership with
celebrated playwright Lloyd Richards (Hugh Marlowe)
and his wife, Karen (Celeste Holm). However, her
private life is almost exclusively managed by
Birdie Coonan (Thelma Ritter); an ever-devoted
house maid with a sharp tongue but soft heart who
will soon become the first to discover a traitor
in their midst.
Into this close knit community arrives the Judas;
backstabber Eve Harrington (Anne Baxter)
masquerading as a doe-eyed ingénue. After
ingratiating herself into Margo's hallowed company
with a sob story of pure fiction, Eve
systematically goes about manipulating Margo's
alliances and friendships; all the while playing
the part of a respectful personal secretary.
Instead, and with her eye firmly on the prize, Eve
has plans to topple Margo from her throne as the
first lady of the American theater.
Eve's ace in the hole is Addison DeWitt, whom Eve
erroneously believes she can extort to her best
effect as she has done with the others. Addison,
however, has more than Eve's career advancement on
his mind – a prospect Eve entertains only
peripherally to maneuver herself into a position
of power within Margo's circle of friends.
However, Eve quickly discovers that there is
nothing as venomous nor as dangerous as a man just
as unscrupulous as her.
Behind the scenes, Davis and Baxter did not get on
– a tension brought to its boiling point when both
were nominated as Best Actress in the Oscar race.
Neither won – leading Davis to forever consider
herself robbed. In retrospect, she probably was.
Davis as Margo is – as Addison might have
concluded for himself - perfection itself; a
stunning tower of the ‘fire' and ‘music'
Mankiewicz describes in his screenplay. When Davis
as Margo forewarns her guests in the film's most
memorable moment to "Fasten your seatbelts. It's
going to be a bumpy night" her tone is fraught in
shades of dark moody bitterness and wily comedic
devilry – as though she despises not only her own
place in the world but is also laughing at it from
the inside.
If Davis always harbored a hint of bitterness at
losing the Oscar, she could at least take
temporary comfort in the afterthought that her
fleeting romance with costar Gary Merrill – a
whirlwind of ‘fire and music' culminated in an
even more short lived marriage. Today, All About
Eve remains as fresh and ever present in the mind.
In a culture where words like ‘instant classic'
are carelessly bandied about with reckless
disregard for their actual meaning, All About Eve
is most deserving of that moniker on a multitude
of levels. It is a perfect movie!
The same cannot be said for Fox's third reissue of
the movie on DVD; a tired regurgitation of the
transfer already available under its ‘studio
classic' line. The chief concern herein is that
the B&W image retains not only a considerable
amount of grain throughout, but that its weak
contrast levels render the entire grayscale
blandly. There are no solid or deep blacks – just
varying tonalities of gray. Whites too are never
bright – just a high register of gray.
Occasionally the image appears a tad too softly
focused. Fine details can be nicely realized,
though rather inconsistently rendered. The audio
is presented in both original mono and
re-channeled stereo.
The biggest improvement on Fox's latest DVD
incarnation is in the extras included. Not only do
we get the two individual commentary tracks, AMC
Backstory about the making of the film and several
brief shorts that were included on the Fox Studio
Classic series disc; Disc 2 of this latest
offering also includes 4 newly produced
featurettes: ‘Directed by Joseph L. Mankiewicz' a
beautiful retrospective on the director's career,
another on his personal life, a reveal of
Mankiewicz's inspiration for ‘the real Eve' and a
special featurette on the Sarah Siddons Society.
(Incidentally, at the time of the film's release,
there was no Sarah Siddons Society. Mankiewicz
made it up. A few short years later, the ‘Society'
was formed.)
After the unexpected success of Whatever Happened
to Baby Jane? (1962) – a grand guignol costarring
Bette Davis and Joan Crawford, director Robert
Aldrich decided that a reunion of sorts was in
order. Ironically, prior to that film's release,
Davis and Crawford were considered has-beens in
Hollywood – a perception echoed to Aldrich by Jack
Warner. "I won't give you a dime for those two
washed up old broads!"
Eventually, Warner begrudgingly green lit
Aldrich's film, though he steadfastly refused the
director rights to shoot it anywhere on the Warner
Bros. backlot. When ‘Baby Jane' proved a runaway
smash, Warner was suddenly chummy with Aldrich,
Crawford and Davis all over again.
‘Chummy', however, was not the way anyone
associated with the project would have described
the daily climate on the set. Davis despised
Crawford and as the shooting schedule progressed
her animosity blossomed into full blown hatred.
Hence, ‘Baby Jane' became a war zone for Bette to
vent all of the hostility she had harbored toward
Crawford.
Although neither actress relished the experience,
the movie's success necessitated a follow-up
project. By now, Aldrich was working at 20th
Century-Fox on another dark story by Henry Farrell
about two women locked in dire conflict; one a
deranged aged socialite, the other her scheming
cousin. Hush, Hush Sweet Charlotte (1964), with
its brooding noir melodrama and schemes of
shocking murder would be the project to reunited
Davis and Crawford on the screen. It was not to
be. After shooting most of her exteriors on
location, Crawford astutely assessed that Davis'
disposition towards her had hardly softened and
shortly thereafter faked a bought of pneumonia to
get out of her contract.
To quell nervous tensions on the set, Aldrich
approached long time Davis friend and co-star,
Olivia de Havilland with the project. Davis
approved and so did de Havilland. With little to
no preparation, de Havilland seized the reigns of
the part, turning in a masterful performance while
smoothing over all of the personal animosities
that Davis had harbored toward Crawford.
Hush, Hush Sweet Charlotte opens with an extended
prologue set on a massive southern plantation in
1927. Boorish plantation owner, Samuel Eugene
Hollis (Victor Buono) is confronting married man,
John Mayhew (Bruce Dern) in his parlor. Seems John
and Hollis' teenage daughter, Charlotte (Davis)
have been carrying on a romantic liaison that has
blossomed into a proposal of marriage. Disgusted
by the prospect that his virginal daughter should
want to run off with a married man, Hollis
threatens Mayhew with certain death should he
pursue Charlotte any further.
That night, at a debutante party on the
plantation, John breaks Charlotte's heart by
telling her that they can never be married. He is
brutally murdered in the conservatory and an
emotionally scarred Charlotte stumbles into the
ballroom, her virginal white gown soaked with
John's blood. But did Charlotte kill her lover?
From here, the narrative takes a quantum leap into
the present. Charlotte is a mentally unstable
middle-age frump, trapped in the decay of her late
father's plantation, slated by city developers for
demolition. Her one true friend is Velma Cruther
(Agnes Moorehead); a dotty, and very crotchety
housemaid. To ease Charlotte's conscience and help
save the family home, Velma reluctantly sends for
Charlotte's snooty cousin, Miriam Deering (de
Havilland).
Miriam's arrival is met with considerable interest
by Charlotte's physician and Miriam's former
flame, Dr. Drew Bayliss (Joseph Cotten). In fact,
it doesn't take long for Miriam and Drew to
concoct a diabolical plot that will rid them both
of Charlotte's instability while making them both
very rich. Using Charlotte's haunted/unchanged
love for John, Miriam and Drew resurrect his ghost
about the plantation – spooking Charlotte at every
turn with memories that appear to come to life and
threaten her very existence. The frame up works –
particularly after Miriam does away with Velma,
who had begun to have her own suspicions.
Miriam decides that Charlotte must be driven
completely mad to be certifiable. In a twist so
manipulatively evil that it is best left
unmentioned herein for first time viewers to
discover on their own, Charlotte believes that she
has accidentally murdered Dr. Bayliss and implores
Miriam to help her conceal her ‘crime.'
Hush, Hush Sweet Charlotte is diabolically
entertaining. The screenplay by Henry Farrell and
Lukas Heller is top notch and terrifying. Casting
is superb. Though Davis clearly distinguishes
herself amongst the crowd, she does not dominate
the film. De Havilland holds her own, brilliantly
playing against type as evil incarnate, as does
Cotten, whose oily lothario is as utterly
repugnant as he is entirely compelling. In the
final analysis, the film gets its shocks and
thrills the old fashioned way – through exemplary
writing, staging and acting.
Fox has reissued Hush Hush Sweet Charlotte as part
of its tribute to Bette Davis 100th birthday. It
had previously been available as part of their
Studio Classic Series (SCS). Unfortunately, there
are discrepancies between these two competing
versions. The new disc's aspect ratio has been
reformatted from its original 1:66:1 to 1:85:1
with a noticeable expansion of visual information
to the left and right of the film frame that is
not in keeping with the director's original
vision. Furthermore, contrast levels on this new
edition have been considerably bumped up – the
result being a loss of fine detail in the middle
register of the grayscale's tonality. Considerable
reduction of age related artifacts in the original
SCS edition are the only plus that this reviewer
can deduce in image refinements on this newer
minting. The audio is presented in both original
mono and re-channeled stereo with minor
differences.
However, perhaps the biggest disappointment on
this reissue is Fox's inexplicable and obtuse
choice to remove Glenn Erickson's thorough audio
commentary from its extra features – replacing it
instead with an isolated score and three
featurettes: two newly produced and one vintage
promotional short subject. There is also a stills
gallery and theatrical trailer included on the new
version.
Star billing in ensemble acting is always tricky
business. In Jean Negulesco's Phone Call From A
Stranger (1952) – a uncanny amalgam of noir
styling, conventional melodrama and a touch of
screwball comedy - it becomes downright confusing.
Shelly Winters is given above the title credit
even though Gary Merrill has infinitely more
screen time. The script by Nunnally Johnson and
I.A.R. Wylie is a tedious mishmash of clichés and
uncertainties with a few brief nuggets of hidden
surprise that seem to come out of nowhere.
The story concerns David L. Trask (Merrill) an
attorney running away from his home life after he
discovers that wife Jane (Helen Westcott) has been
unfaithful. Telephoning Jane from the airport,
David next buys his ticket under an assumed name.
He is ‘picked up' by lonely ex-actress/former
stripper Bianca Carr (Shelley Winters) while
waiting for their flight in the terminal and
thereafter also becomes friends with two other
passengers; traveling salesman Edmund Hoke (Keenan
Wynn) and Dr. Robert Fortness (Michael Rennie).
The flight takes off under a terrible storm and is
grounded in Vegas overnight. Dr. Fortness
confesses a deep dark family secret to David, whom
he is hoping will be able to provide some much
needed legal council. It seems that one night not
so very long ago the good doctor departed a
fashionable party with fellow colleague, Dr. Tim
Brooks (Hugh Beaumont) en route to treat a patient
at a nearby hospital. Unfortunately, David's
cockiness and the influence of alcohol contributed
to a head on collision where Brooks and all of the
passengers in the other vehicle were killed
instantly.
Lying on his hospital bed, Fortness tells
presiding physician, Dr. Luther Fletcher (Harry
Cheshire) that it was Brooks, not he who was
driving the car. Fortness' story is backed by his
dutiful wife, Claire (Beatrice Straight) even
though she knows the truth about the accident. The
secret eventually tears Fortness' family apart.
Meanwhile, inside the airport terminal, Edmund is
proudly passing around a picture of his wife,
Marie (Bette Davis). * Aside: the photo is
actually an airbrushed image with Davis' face
pasted onto the body of a bathing beauty pin-up.
Bianca jokingly tells Edmund that he is far too
lucky to have Marie as his wife. Fortness agrees.
For both Fortness and Bianca, Edmund is
misperceived as boorish, grating and nonsensical.
However David finds Edmund – if not enlightening –
then, at least amusing.
With weather conditions all clear, their plane
takes off the next morning only to suffer ice
build up on its engine and wings. It crashes,
killing all but three on board. David is the only
member of his troop to survive and he spends the
rest of the film's running time reluctantly
contacting the family members of Dr. Fortness,
Edmund and Bianca to relay their final hours and
provide closure and solace to each family.
In Fortness' case, David is able to reunite Claire
– who had become estranged from her husband - with
their embittered son, Jerry (Ted Donaldson). In
Edmund's circumstance, David learns that Marie has
been paralyzed for many years following an
ill-fated elopement with her lover that Edmund
forgave.
The most peculiar of all reconciliations, played
out in flashback like a bad screwball moment
ripped from another film, involves David's brief
interaction with nightclub proprietor Sallie Carr
(Evelyn Varden) and Bianca's estranged husband,
Mike (Craig Stevens). Possessive mother-in-law,
Sallie hated Bianca's independence – fabricating a
persona for her that reads more that of the
heartless vixen. Sensing Sallie's relish in
demonizing Bianca, David fabricates a bit of his
own wish fulfillment about Bianca's audition with
Rodgers and Hammerstein; thereby deflating
Sallie's claim that her daughter-in-law was a no
good useless failure.
As film entertainment, Phone Call From A Stranger
is acutely convoluted; it's plot suffering from
too many half ideas that never meld into one
complete narrative. Merrill does his usual laconic
‘world weary' loner routine with aloof
disenchantment. He doesn't seem terribly engaged,
but rather trudging from one plot point to the
next with a ‘am I there yet?' mentality that, at
times, is rather oppressive.
Bette Davis is wasted in her near cameo. Truly,
Davis' acceptance of the part of Marie (something
any actress could have played blindfolded) has to
be one of the all time cinema curiosities. How
desperate for work was she? Winters is a bit long
in the tooth to be the tart with a proverbial
heart of gold but she pulls it off for the most
part. Wynn overplays his hand with a painful
example of ham acting. In the end, the characters
and the plot do not gel the way they should. The
results are mediocre at best.
Fox Home Video provides a beautiful DVD transfer.
The B&W image exhibits exceptional tonality in its
grayscale. Blacks are deep and solid. Whites are
nearly pristine. Contrast levels are perfectly
balanced. Age related artifacts are rare and do
not distract. The audio is mono as originally
recorded and presented at an adequate listening
level. Extras are limited to an interactive press
book and lobby and stills gallery.
Despite its subject matter – that of political
intrigue in the court of Elizabeth I, and a cast
that includes Bette Davis, Richard Todd and Joan
Collins, Henry Koster's The Virgin Queen (1955) is
a turgid unremarkable recanting of English history
made fictional for the benefit of a good romantic
yarn.
Davis had already shaved into her hairline once
before to play the enigmatic English ruler for
1939's The Private Lives of Elizabeth and Essex.
Then, the wordy foreplay between Davis and costar
Errol Flynn had been based on a magnificent stage
play from imminent playwright Maxwell Anderson
that had managed to generate sparks beneath the
Elizabethan collars and cuffs.
On The Virgin Queen, the script by Mindret Lord
and Harry Brown is rather uninspired – moving its
characters like chess pieces about this board of
faux history. Originally, Lord and Brown had
wanted to write a story, not about Elizabeth, but
Sir Walter Raleigh. Davis' involvement on the
project necessitated a rethinking of that idea and
hence the resulting film developed along the lines
of a tailor-made vehicle for Davis' talents.
The story opens with the arrival of Lord Leicester
(Herbert Marshall) on foot at an inn after his
carriage has been trapped in the mud. To the inn's
carousing inhabitance Leicester offers a small
purse of gold as remuneration if they will help
him get on his way as quickly as possible. Sir
Christopher Hatton (Robert Douglas) laughs off the
suggestion that he sully himself even in service
to the Queen. Sir Walter Raleigh (Richard Todd),
however, takes heed of the proposition as a means
of positioning himself with an audience at court.
The ploy works. Raleigh meets Elizabeth (Bette
Davis) and the two shares an initial intimacy of
sparring remarks overheard by one of the Queen's
ladies in waiting - Beth Throgmorton (Joan
Collins). Beth immediately catches Raleigh's eye
though she, recognizing his opportunistic streak,
discourages Raleigh's advances at every turn.
Raleigh next asks Elizabeth for three ships that
he will sail in England's name to the new world
for treasure. Unable to convince Elizabeth of the
feasibility in his plan, Raleigh sulks off like a
petulant child. However, Elizabeth's loss is
Beth's gain.
A quite romance develops between Beth and Raleigh
– a pas deux thwarted when Elizabeth has a sudden
change of heart. She grants Raleigh a commission
to build one ship to suit his own fashion and
purpose – The Golden Falcon – which she also
grants him to sail to the new world in England's
name. Driven by ego, Raleigh temporarily forsakes
Beth to toil on the designs of his grand vessel
with friend, Lord Derry (Dan O'Herlihy).
Meanwhile, court spy, Chadwick (Jay Robinson)
alerts the Queen of a cautious secret; that Beth
and Raleigh have not only become lovers, but have,
in fact, married without her consent and that Beth
is currently with Raleigh's child.
Furious, Elizabeth orders Raleigh's imprisonment
as a traitor. Learning of Beth's pregnancy too
late, Raleigh instructs Lord Derry to flee with
his wife into the Scottish highlands. The pair is
captured on the road by Sir Christopher and Derry
is killed in the resulting duel. Locked in the
Tower of London, Raleigh faces certain death –
more so after Elizabeth arrives to command that he
repent for his sins against the crown only to
discover that he is more obstinate than ever. In
reply, Elizabeth cannot bring herself to kill
Raleigh. Instead, she commands him to board the
Golden Falcon with Beth and bring back to her the
promised riches from the new world.
The inconsistencies between history and fact are
many and obvious, beginning with Lord Leicester's
initial befriending of Raleigh at the inn. Lord
Leicester was in fact Robert Dudley (played by
Errol Flynn in 1939's Private Lives of Elizabeth
and Essex) – the Queen's great love during her
youth whom she was forced to behead after Robert's
determination to rule England by marriage
threatened Elizabeth's own political safety.
In direct comparison to The Private Lives of
Elizabeth and Essex, The Virgin Queen is a more
restrained and subdued production in totem. Its
sets are less spectacular, though not perhaps its
costumes. Davis is in fine voice and temperament
as Elizabeth – pouring out equal portions of
womanly contempt and authoritarian command.
Richard Todd makes a valiant enough Raleigh,
though he is not the man of history as much as he
has been forced into that romantic mold of
interest to all women who fancy their heroes in
tights and a cod piece. In the final analysis, The
Virgin Queen is second tier entertainment; just
another period drama from a vintage when such
offerings were plentiful.
Fox Home Video's anamorphic Cinemascope image
exhibits a rather appealing visual presentation.
Colors are rich, bold and vibrant. Flesh tones are
a tad pasty at times. Fine details are generally
realized, though image sharpness is often less
than stellar. Age related artifacts are absent for
a very smooth quality throughout. The audio is 5.1
Dolby Digital remastering of the original 6 track
stereo. Dialogue is directionalized. Music cues
have a very nice spread. Extras include an
isolated music track and ‘making of' featurette.
Based on Marryam Modell's mystery novel, Seth
Holt's The Nanny (1965) emerges as a rather
disjointed thriller in which bewilderment and
uncertainty generate more questions than answers.
Initially, the project had been proposed to Greer
Garson – who wisely could not see her way to
playing either dowdy or demonic and thus bowed out
of the film. In restructuring the novel into movie
format, screenwriter Jimmy Sangster omitted
Modell's references to possible sexual abuse, thus
diffusing much of the logic for all the tension
that was to follow.
Bette Davis is ‘Nanny' – a proper English
governess and housekeeper employed at the home of
the Queen's messenger, stoic Bill Fane (James
Villier) and his emotionally fragile wife,
Virginia (Wendy Craig). The two are supposed to
retrieve their son, Joey (William Dix) from a
nearby sanitarium where the boy had been placed
for observation and disciplinary reformation after
the death of his sister, Susy (Angharad Aubrey).
The institution's headmaster, Dr. Beamaster
(Maurice Denham) informs Bill that Joey is far
from cured. In fact, Joey has recently accelerated
his devilish pranks to terrorize the institution's
matron Mrs. Griggs (Nora Gordon). Joey reluctantly
returns with Bill and Nanny to the family's
fashionable London flat, but he is increasingly
bitter, rude and condescending to everyone –
particularly Nanny and his mother.
Joey's allegations – that Nanny is evil and out to
poison him – seem unfounded conjecture at best.
Indeed, Nanny goes out of her way to be kind to
Joey. Meanwhile, Joey befriends Bobbie Medman
(Pamela Franklin) the randy teenage daughter of
Dr. Medman (Jack Watling) who is their upstairs
neighbor. Bill is called away on weekend business.
That evening, Virginia succumbs to a curious
poisoning of her meat pie at dinner and is rushed
to hospital by Dr. Medman to have her stomach
pumped. Virginia's sister, Pen (Jill Bennett) is
called by Nanny to baby-sit for Joey.
So far, the narrative makes perfect sense with
Joey being perceived as the evil in the Fane
family home. Ah, but then screenwriter Sangster
interjects a few plot twists which damage the
credibility of his entire story. First up is a
flashback sequence in which the audience is privy
to Susy's death. Previously, Joey has told Bobbie
that Nanny forcibly held Susy's head underwater in
the bathtub.
Instead, the flashback reveals that the child lost
her footing on the tub's edge while trying to
retrieve her doll – falling unconscious into the
tub with the curtain drawn. Making ready a bath
for the children, Nanny – who was not home at the
time of the accident – starts the water without
drawing open the curtains first. The tub fills
with water and the child drowns accidentally. This
big reveal deflates the prospect that Nanny is
deliberately homicidal.
The second problematic element that Sangster
infuses into the latter half of the film has to do
with a rather sudden and unexpected escalation in
violence directed at the family by Nanny. It
begins with the reveal that Pen suffers from a
heart ailment that requires her to take a daily
regiment of pills in order to survive. Waking in
the middle of the night, Pen – who does not
believe Joey's claims about Nanny – suddenly
becomes suspicious when she finds Nanny standing
in the kitchen with a pillow. Pressed to the
point, Nanny reveals that the pillow is for Joey's
bed. Pen suffers an attack and Nanny, rather than
saving her life, carries her to bed where she
patiently waits for her to die. Nanny attempts to
break into Joey's bedroom where he has barricaded
himself and smother him with the pillow. He is
spared such a fate at the last minute and Nanny is
brought to justice.
What is most confusing about these final few
moments in the film is that they shift the onus of
evil incarnate away from Joey – who until then has
been the sole purveyor of diabolical mischief that
he genuinely seems to derive pleasure from – to
Nanny – who has displayed not one iota of
referenced tendencies to do harm to the family
unit.
The screenplay by Sangster offers no explanation
for Nanny's psychosis – no logical reason why she
should suddenly turn on her lifelong commitment to
the Fane family whom she has been involved with
since Virginia's rearing. If anything, the
flashback reveal of Susy's accidental death
weakens the story's credibility that Nanny is our
villain. If anything, Nanny is a tragic figure –
the wrong person at the wrong time whose actions
unintentionally takes the life of an innocent
child, but haunts her memory for the rest of film.
In truth, the character of Joey is the most
problematic aspect of the film. As played by Dix,
Joey is entirely unlikable or, for the most part,
unredeemable. Take for example Joey's emotionless
response to being informed by Dr. Medman that his
mother has been poisoned and will have to be
rushed to the hospital. Herein, a ‘normal child'
might have seized the opportunity to inform Medman
of his suspicions about Nanny and use the
situation more wisely for leverage. Instead,
Joey's aloofness and lack of allegations play more
like an extension of some innately perverse need
to be self-destructive, conniving and
manipulative.
Bette Davis's performance is exemplary throughout
– the very embodiment of English propriety and
decorum. Pamela Franklin is enigmatic in the few
brief scenes that she appears. The least affecting
turn comes from James Villier – more menacing than
fatherly and quite suspect for the chills and
thrills until the screenplay jettisons him from
the duration of the story. In the final analysis,
The Nanny is diluted entertainment.
Fox Home Video's DVD is disappointing at best. The
anamorphic B&W image is faded throughout. Blacks
are dull gray. Whites are dirty. Film grain is
present as are age related artifacts. Contrast
levels are weak and inconsistently rendered. The
audio is mono but has a muffled characteristic at
the beginning that renders some of the dialogue
virtually inaudible. The orchestral music over the
main title is shrill. Extras include a restoration
comparison, TV spots, trailers and interactive
press book. |