Dark Victory [Warner]

 

Do you know what your children are watching?

By NICK ZEGARAC

In 1939 Bette Davis was at the peak of her powers as a professional actress. After an initially rocky start to her career, Davis proved the old adage that "if at first you don't succeed, try, try again." Aside from being one of Hollywood's highest paid actresses, she also had Jack Warner eating out of the palm of her hand. And although Davis and Warner often butted heads over projects and script approval, on these occasions Warner was usually the one to acquiesce.

"Dark Victory" (1939) was just such a project in which Warner and Davis didn't see eye to eye. In fact, after an early consultation, Warner was rumored to have said, "Who the hell wants to see a story about a girl with a brain tumor?" Apparently, a lot of people did. On its initial release "Dark Victory" was a box office dynamo, elevating the level of prestige for both Davis and the studio and earning the actress her second Best Actress Oscar nomination (Davis lost to Vivien Leigh, as Scarlett O'Hara in Gone With The Wind).

"Dark Victory" is the story of haughty and exclusive socialite, Judith Traherne (Davis). She's generally devil-may-care. However, lately Judy's been seeing double -- literally. She confides the deteriorating state of health to her best friend and personal secretary -- Ann King (Geraldine Fitzgerald). Unbeknownst to Judith, Ann tells family doctor and personal friend, Parsons (Henry Travers) of Judy's condition. Together, the two suckle the reluctant Judy into a professional consultation with Dr. Fredrick Steele (George Brent). Steele's initial diagnosis of a brain tumor is complicated by a growing affection for his patient. When he operates on Judy, only to discover that her case is both rare and terminal -- he and Ann concoct an elaborate lie to protect Judith from the truth. But this is a secret that will not stay buried.

All around the acting in this finely wrought melodrama from director, Edmund Goulding is first rate. Davis has never been more poignant, tragic, sympathetic and understanding. Her performance throbs with an equilibrium of finely crafted emotions. As her sympathetic physician/turned lover, George Brent delivers an understated tour de force. The other outstanding bit of acting that deserves mention herein is Geraldine Fitzgerald's brilliant bit as Judy's most loyal companion. As Ann, Fitzgerald generates a level of sincerity that is so unique and mesmerizing, it's a shock and a wonder she didn't have a more prolific acting career after this film. Humphrey Bogart, in an early appearance as Michael O'Leery, makes a rather unconvincing, if embittered, Irish stable hand. But Ronald Reagan is quite engaging as Judy's loyal, if alcoholic, friend, Alec Hamm.

After years of having to contend with downright shoddy transfers of this classic weepy, Warner Brothers has gone back to the drawing board and come up a winner on this newly restored and remastered DVD. The black in white image is, in a word, superb. Though age-related artifacts persist, these have been greatly reduced from previous transfers. There is no edge enhancement for a picture that is smooth, yet sharp and most pleasing on the eyes. The grayscale exhibits an amazing amount of fine detail throughout with deep solid blacks and very clean whites. Truly, there is nothing that will disappoint on this occasion. The audio has been nicely cleaned up. It's mono, as originally recorded, but presented without the nuisance of pops and hiss that accompanied previous incarnations of this film on home video. A new audio commentary and production featurette augment your viewing experience. So break out a fresh box of Kleenex. "Dark Victory" is at last worthy of all of your tears on DVD.

» Buy the DVD


Ask us about exclusive sponsorships


©  Critics Inc. All rights reserved. See Terms of Use.

 

AMAZON.COM