Giant [Warner]

 

Do you know what your children are watching?

By NICK ZEGARAC

Director George Steven's "Giant" (1956) is, well… one heck of a giant film experience, full of lusty and intensely drawn characters that speak to the boisterous Texans that populated Edna Ferber's best selling novel. The film stars Elizabeth Taylor as Leslie Lynnton, a rather priggish -- if drop dead gorgeous -- young woman, whose pending marriage to Sir David Karfrey (Rod Taylor, in an early and fleeting on screen appearance) is thwarted by the sudden appearance of Jordon Benedict (Rock Hudson). Then again, what woman could resist the manly virtue of Rock Hudson in his prime, and, before the realization that he preferred the same as his female costars?

Seems Jordon is bent on buying a stallion for his Texas ranch. Yet, in only a few short days he falls for Leslie, and she for him. Together as man and wife they return to Jordon's sprawling Texas cattle ranch -- about as stark and jolting a departure from the green pastures of New England as anything can be. At first Leslie doesn't seem to fit in to her new digs. Her subtle conflicts over housekeeping with Jordon's overly possessive sister, Luz (Mercedes McCambridge) are a bone of contention and pride that Luz is certain she will win. However, when Jordon makes it clear that Leslie is now the lady of the house, Luz takes to punishing a stallion -- in Jordon's stead -- by digging her spurs into his side. She is thrown from her ride and killed. But that's only the beginning of Leslie's problems. Accidentally befriending Jordon's jealous rival, the impoverished Jett Rink (James Dean in his last role), Leslie is torn between Jett's lilting way with the Mexican natives that populate the ranch and whom she feels a kinship towards, and, Jordon's racist view of the Mexican's place as inferior to whites among society.

The film really has two conflicting flavors that meet somewhere in the middle. The first half of this epic (of which some critics have suggested was partly the model for television's most successful night time soap -- Dallas), is a love story gone bad, in which Leslie and Jordon gradually drift apart but are held together by the birth of their children, son Jordon Jr. (Dennis Hopper) and daughter, Luz Jr. (Carroll Baker). Eventually, neither child will live up to parental expectations. Jordon Jr. marries a Mexican woman -- forcing his father's hand at re-evaluating his own racist beliefs, while Luz Jr. has her heart broken after carrying on with the elderly Jett. The high point of the second half of the film comes in a showdown between Jett and Jordon Sr. on the eve that Jett's casino and hotel is supposed to mark a new era in the renovation of Dallas' social nightlife.

Director, Stevens keeps his narrative tight during the second half -- which is rather odd, considering how the first half tends to fall off in bits and pieces of meandering explorations between romantic melodrama and social commentary. Regardless of these shortcomings, "Giant" was a colossal success upon its theatrical release; its one shadow of regret falling across the untimely demise of James Dean, who died only days after completing his performance on the set.

I wish I had better news for fans of this film, but the two-disc collector's edition from Warner is a colossal disappointment. Minted from a restored print, made long before digital restoration technology had taken hold in the industry, the picture elements on "Giant" are worn, faded and miserably mis-registered in spots. Worse, the widescreen image has not been anamorphically enhanced for widescreen televisions.

(Aside: Nearly a year before the U.S. version debuted, a Canadian single disc of this movie was made available in anamorphic widescreen from Warner Home Video, and with all of the extras of this new two disc edition, made available on its flip side. Presumably because Warner realized that it did not have permission from Jane Withers to use her footage in a documentary that was included on this disc -- the single flipper was never released in the United States and shortly after its issue in Canada, was pulled from shelves. The Canadian version remains the only version of "Giant" to be enhanced for widescreen T.V.'s.)

Regardless of this oversight, the image quality of both the flipper and this two disc is the same, with only the most marginal of improvements afford the Canadian version because of its improved resolution. Still, the picture is a resounding disappointment. Flesh tones are never anything but pasty and overly pink. Most of the colors are a muddy mess, marred by the addition of considerable film grain, edge enhancement, shimmering of fine details and a lot of pixelization. Overall then, the video quality is anything but smooth and often, distracts one from the performances. The audio is also dismal; strident sounding in spots, muffled in others, and with far too much electronic enhancement to be anything close to natural. Extras include the aforementioned Withers footage documentary and several other anomalies, including the film's theatrical trailer, an intro from George Stevens Jr. and several promotional junkets covering the film's premiere and general release.

» Buy the DVD


Ask us about exclusive sponsorships


©  Critics Inc. All rights reserved. See Terms of Use.

 

AMAZON.COM