Punky Brewster: The Complete First Season [Shout! Factory]

 

Do you know what your children are watching?

By WADE GOSSETT

The casual viewer who pops in the first DVD of the first season of 1984's "Punky Brewster" may quickly decide that the series was little more than an early '80s affectation, something like "Three's Company," "One Day at a Time," or any of the other unfunny sitcoms that were released during that period. The late '70s and early 80s were a conservative media period after all, and humor needs a liberal sensibility in order to challenge the culture and the prevailing norms.

However, you'll be wrong about "Punky." Getting over the rather mediocre, cheap looking set design, the pasty-looking patina of early video, and acting that was awkward and self-conscious at times, reveals a touching, smart sitcom that kids will enjoy very much.

Channeling Shirley Temple, Soleil Moon Frye stars as an abandoned little girl who's cute and clever and tough. Along with her dog Brandon she brings joy and adventure to the staid life of grumpy, old loner Henry (George Gaynes).

I liked the basic message, which is that a family doesn't have to subscribe to preconceived notions of what a family is. Any two loving people who are obviously happy together and can take care of each other can indeed be a family. Nevertheless, it is kids that will truly enjoy Punky's escapades. Both my kids, eight and five years of age, loved spunky Punky.

The improbably named Soleil Moon Frye was a natural child actress, as charismatic and likable as Shirley Temple ever was. Moreover, the plots, especially the early ones, are easy to understand. Obviously aiming "Punky" at younger viewers, the actors tend to enunciate overly well, and I'm pretty certain that the awkwardness I thought I detected in the acting is really an attempt at making everything perfectly clear to post-toddlers and pre-teens.

The typical episode finds Punky in mostly (but not always) trifling conflicts with Henry -- conflicts that are of course eventually resolved to everybody's satisfaction. For instance, in "Punky Gets Her Own Room," Punky convinces an unwilling Henry to give up his study so that she can turn it into her own bright and cheery bedroom; in "Parents Night" Henry, who's still learning how to be a dad, has to decide whether to show up at Punky's school when he has to work.

The set contains all 23 episodes of the first season, plus 2 hours of the Saturday morning cartoon, "It's Punky Brewster." There's no commentary track, but there are short interviews with creator and executive producer David W. Duclon, writer Barry Vigon, and actresses Cherie Johnson and Ami Foster. Unfortunately, there's nothing by the stars, George Gaynes and Soleil Moon Frye. Both are alive and well and still working so contemporary interviews would have been very welcome, especially by nostalgic fans who'd be curious to know how the two actors have fared over the years.

» Buy the DVD


Ask us about exclusive sponsorships


©  Critics Inc. All rights reserved. See Terms of Use.

 

AMAZON.COM