The Way We Were [Columbia]

 

Do you know what your children are watching?

By NICK ZEGARAC

While most musical stars quickly fell out of favor with film audiences and faded into obscurity after the last great swell of movie musicals in the late 1960s, Barbra Streisand emerged from this downswing virtually unscathed, proving once and for all that her talent was far more extensive than mere musical theater. In "The Way We Were" Streisand is Katie -- a Jewish, pro-communist sympathizer who fights against political propaganda every chance that she gets. In pre-war America this stance wins her very few supporters and even fewer friends.

One admirer is Hubble Gardner (Robert Redford), a whitebread born to WASP privilege -- so Waspish, in fact, that it hurts. The unlikely romance that blossoms between these two is essentially what fuels this well-tailored history lesson that picks up at the end of the second World War and explores the HUAC anti-American trials and the McCarthy witch hunt against suspected communists in Hollywood that followed.

Though Katie and Hubble argue over nearly everything, their romance seems strangely and ideally suited for a long while, though it is ultimately doomed to a bittersweet end. As with most romantic movies of the 1970s, getting to the final fade-out is not so important as the circumstances one has to go through to get there. Only in the last half hour does the film's attention to narrative detail tend to somewhat fall apart as director Sidney Pollack desperately tries to cram in way too much in too little running time -- thereby alienating something of the carefully crafted romance that began his story.

For the most part, Columbia has given us "The Way We Were" the way we remember it. Colors can be rich and bold at times, though somewhat washed out during night scenes. There's also an excessive amount of film grain and aliasing, shimmering and edge enhancement in specific scenes, particularly the one where Katie and Hubble have their first serious discussion at an outdoor pub after he confides in her that he has sold his first story. Overall, inconsistencies in image quality are sporadic. The audio has been remixed but continues to sound strident and unnatural. There are even several cases where it sounds dubbed over. Extras include a generally self-congratulatory making-of featurette that is rather weak on details and full of praise for cast and crew and a theatrical trailer.

» Buy the DVD


Ask us about exclusive sponsorships


©  Critics Inc. All rights reserved. See Terms of Use.

 

AMAZON.COM